The Inn At 2Nd & C, Eureka - Reviews, Room Options & Prices 2025

Book and save

up to 10%

compared to Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

124 C Street, Eureka, California, United States, CA 95501

“The Inn's central location made exploring downtown Eureka a breeze!”view full review

The Inn At 2Nd & C, a 3-star boutique hotel housed in the historic Eagle House Victorian from 1886, overlooks Humboldt Bay with its grand Theater Ballroom featuring a stained glass ceiling and wrap-around balcony.

Historic Antique Rooms

The Inn At 2Nd & C offers uniquely furnished rooms with antique pieces and modern amenities. Premium Deluxe King Rooms feature California king beds and sitting areas, while select suites include pull-out sofa beds with Tempur Pedic mattresses.

Local Fresh Dining

Tavern 1888 serves market-fresh coastal cuisine sourced from Humboldt County. Phatsy's specializes in tapas-style dinners and house-made desserts using local organic ingredients.

Meeting Event Facilities

The business center provides work tables, projectors, screens, and dry-erase boards. The ballroom's wooden dance floor and stage create an ideal event space.

Historic District Location

Located in Old Town Eureka, The Inn at 2nd & C stands near the Carson Mansion and Morris Graves Museum of Art. The property is 18.5 miles from Arcata-Eureka Airport.

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

Deluxe King Room

Max:

2 persons

28 m²

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Shower

Heating

room details

Check Prices

Deluxe Queen Room

Max:

2 persons

24 m²

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Shower

Heating

room details

Check Prices

Deluxe Queen Room Two Queen Beds

Max:

2 persons

28 m²

Bed options:

2 King Size Beds

Shower

Heating

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

A guide to all available transportation options

City Centre

Eureka600 m

Airports

Arcata-Eureka (ACV) 27.0 km

Bus

Bus stop300 m

Facilities

Experience a variety of amenities at the boutique hotel, crafted to ensure your comfort and unforgettable moments

Charming Vintage Decor

“My stay in room #40 was absolutely good. The antique carved furniture and quirky touches throughout the room gave it a cozy Victorian atmosphere, making me feel like I had entered a beautifully preserved time capsule. It was spacious, well-kept, and the linens were so comfortable that I felt right at home.” view full review

Refreshing Shower Experience

“I thoroughly enjoyed the bathroom in my room. The shower had magnificent water pressure, a welcome surprise after long days of exploring. It wasn't just practical; it reminded me of a small luxury that really added to the experience of my stay.” view full review

Comfortable Sleep Haven

“The bedroom was my sanctuary during my stay. The bed was incredibly comfortable, allowing me to unwind after a full day of activities. The atmosphere was inviting, and I appreciated the unique quirks of the room, which all contributed to a restful night's sleep.” view full review

Charming Breakfast Room

“The breakfast area was simply good! Featuring plush blue sofas and quaint antique furniture, I enjoyed a calm start to my mornings. Though the selection was limited, the cozy ambiance made for a pleasant gathering place to enjoy coffee and pastries before heading out for the day.” view full review

General

No smoking on site
Wi-Fi
Parking
Pets allowed
Luggage storage
Lift
Smoke detectors
Fire extinguishers
Key access

Sports & Fitness

Canoeing
Hiking
Fishing

Guest Parking

Electric kettle

Services

Tours/Ticket assistance
Welcome drink
Happy hour

Dining

Restaurant
Bar/ Lounge area

Business

Meeting/ Banquet facilities

Children

Cots

Spa & Leisure

Beach access
Live entertainment

Room features

Heating
Sitting area
Tea and coffee facilities

Self-catering

Electric kettle

Media

Flat-screen TV

Room decor

Carpeted floor

Location

124 C Street, Eureka, California, United States, CA 95501

Map view

124 C Street, Eureka, California, United States, CA 95501

City landmarks

Landmark

Carson Mansion

2.7 km

Landmark

Eureka Slough

730 m

Landmark

Indian Island

1.2 km

Landmark

Woodley Island

1.0 km

Museum

Redwood Discovery Museum

1.3 km

Museum

Humboldt Bay Maritime Museum

2.2 km

Island

Daby Island

1.7 km

Landmark

Costco Wholesale

1.7 km

Landmark

Blue Ox Millworks and Historic Village

2.0 km

Park

Sequoia Park Zoo

3.7 km

Landmark

Cooper Gulch Recreation Center

2.4 km

Park

Samoa Beach

2.5 km

Landmark

Mad River Slough

2.4 km

Landmark

Samoa Peninsula

2.4 km

Park

Fort Humboldt State Historic Park

3.4 km

Landmark

Eureka Dog Park

2.9 km

Landmark

Six Rivers National Forest Headquarters

2.7 km

Landmark

Bounce-A-Palooza

3.1 km

Garden

Sequoia Park Garden

3.7 km

Landmark

McKay Community Forest

4.2 km

Landmark

Arcata Bay

4.4 km

Nearby

Square

Old Town Eureka

540 m

Museum

Morris Graves Museum of Art

540 m

Museum

Clarke Historical Museum

540 m

Gallery

HSU First Street Gallery

540 m

Theatre

Arkley Center for the Performing Arts

540 m

525 2nd St #105

Eureka Main Street

540 m

518 A St

Kinetic Museum Eureka

540 m

Theatre

North Coast Repertory Theater

540 m

Restaurants

Los Bagels

210 m

403 2nd St

Denny's

330 m

136 5th St

Living the Dream Ice Cream

460 m

1 F St # C1

Starbucks

490 m

326 5th St

The Vance Cafe

400 m

525 2nd St

Surfside Burger Shack

540 m

445 5th St Between E & F st

Wendy's

480 m

529 Broadway Broadway & 6th

Mike's Drive-Up

460 m

637 Broadway

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience.

56%

enjoyed the hotel and would happily stay again

5.6/10

Guest rating

Rooms

8.0

Location

8.6

Service

8.4

Dining

8.6

Erik

United States, March 2025

5.6/10

I had a mixed experience at The Inn At 2nd & C. The hotel definitely has a unique charm with its historic decor, and the staff was incredibly warm and accommodating, really making me feel welcome. However, the surrounding area felt a bit rough, with some vagrants on the streets, which made me hesitant to explore after dark. Overall, I enjoyed the ambiance and the delicious food, but the location gave me pause.

Rooms

8.0

The room was unique and spacious, with a distinct character that reflected the hotel's history.

Service

9.0

The staff were super friendly and went out of their way to help me with my questions.

Location

6.0

The hotel boasts a great location near the water, but the surrounding area felt a bit concerning due to some local activity.

Dining

9.0

I was pleasantly surprised by the gourmet meal at Tavern 1888; the food was creative and really stood out.

Facilities

8.0

Common areas were cozy and inviting, perfect for relaxing and socializing.

Martin

United States, December 2024

6.2/10

I had a lovely stay at The Inn At 2Nd & C. The unique decor and spacious room made it nice, although the historic building's age added a bit of a musty smell initially. The staff were incredibly warm and attentive, enhancing my experience during my visit. Overall, the charm of the hotel and its delicious breakfast options made it a great choice! 😊

Rooms

9.0

My room was spacious and uniquely decorated, which added to the charm. The tall ceilings and cozy fireplace were good, though I did notice the windows could benefit from better blackout curtains.

Service

10.0

The staff were engaging and knowledgeable, always ready to assist with any requests or offer information about the area. Their friendly demeanor truly made me feel welcome.

Location

10.0

The hotel is perfectly situated in the historic district, close to various attractions and dining options, making it super convenient to explore Eureka.

Dining

9.0

I thoroughly enjoyed the breakfast, which was satisfying and provided a great opportunity to interact with other guests. The on-site dining options showcased some exquisite dishes that I won't forget!

Facilities

8.0

The common areas were well-designed and inviting for relaxation and social interaction. Plus, the ample free parking made my stay hassle-free.

Wayne

United States, December 2024

5.2/10

I enjoyed my stay at The Inn At 2Nd & C, appreciating the beautiful historic decor and the welcoming staff. However, the room I stayed in felt a bit cramped for the price, and there was significant street noise that affected my sleep.

Rooms

6.5

My Deluxe King Room was beautifully furnished, but I found it smaller than I expected and lacking adequate storage space for personal items. However, the bed was comfortable and the linens soft, which helped.

Service

8.0

The check-in process was smooth, and the staff was incredibly warm and accommodating, always ready to assist with any questions I had.

Location

8.5

The hotel is conveniently located in the heart of downtown Eureka, close to shops and restaurants, which made it easy to explore the area. I appreciated its historic setting amidst the charm of the older part of town.

Dining

8.0

I had dinner at Tavern 1888 and the meal was nice, especially the halibut and crispy duck breast. The creativity in their menu was quite impressive.

Facilities

7.0

The hotel had nice common areas for relaxation and offered a small continental breakfast. However, I would have liked more variety in the breakfast options.

John

United States, November 2024

5.8/10

I had a lovely stay at The Inn At 2Nd & C. The historic ambiance gave it a unique charm, and the spacious room I stayed in was beautifully decorated with antiques. While the breakfast options were tasty, I felt a bit more variety would have been nice. Overall, the warm and accommodating staff made my experience enjoyable.

Rooms

10.0

My room was spacious with a good view, beautifully furnished with an electric fireplace and quality linens. It was immaculately clean, which I greatly appreciated.

Service

10.0

The staff were consistently friendly and attentive, always willing to help and share insights about the hotel and local area.

Location

10.0

The hotel is perfectly located in the historic center of Eureka, making it easy to walk to various attractions, shops, and restaurants.

Dining

9.0

I really enjoyed the food at the on-site restaurant. The quality and creativity in the dishes stood out, and I had a fantastic meal at Phatsy Klein's lounge.

Facilities

8.0

The amenities were great, but I missed having a refrigerator and microwave in my room. I did appreciate the extra features like yoga sessions and free parking.

Anthony

United States, November 2024

5.2/10

My stay at The Inn At 2Nd & C was a mix of unique charm and some frustrations. The historic atmosphere of the hotel was truly captivating, with its antiques and inviting common areas. However, I found the parking situation quite troublesome and the staff's inattentiveness was disappointing. Overall, it had its moments of delight, but there are certainly areas for improvement.

Rooms

7.0

The room I stayed in was spacious and beautifully decorated, reflecting the hotel's unique character. However, the lack of some common amenities made my experience slightly less comfortable than expected.

Service

5.0

While the staff displayed warmth at times, I encountered instances of rudeness, particularly regarding parking issues, which detracted from my overall experience.

Location

9.0

The hotel's location is fantastic, right in the heart of Old Town with plenty within walking distance. It made exploring the area easy and enjoyable.

Dining

8.0

Dining at the hotel provided some delicious options, and I enjoyed the creative menu offerings. The breakfast was tasty but could benefit from a bit more variety.

Facilities

6.0

The common areas were inviting and well-designed, perfect for relaxing. However, the parking situation was quite inconvenient, as it's not guaranteed and can be troublesome during events.